
Series
ããã€ããã®æ°ã«ãªãåœéåå
æ°ããªãè åšãæ»èªå·¥å ŽïŒreview millïŒã
äœè€ ç¿
24/9/24
åå¿ ç€Ÿå€§åŠ
ïŒïŒãç¶ã»ãªãŒãã³ãµã€ãšã³ã¹ã®ããŸãé£èŒäžïŒ
ãååã®é£èŒã§ã¯ç¹éå·ã«ãã£ãŠæ¯ããããæ°åã¡ã¬ãžã£ãŒãã«ã®ååã玹ä»ããããã§ããã®åé¡ç¹ã«ã€ããŠã¯ãæ å ±ã®ç§åŠãšæè¡ãèªã§å§ãŸãæ°é£èŒããç¶ã»ãªãŒãã³ãµã€ãšã³ã¹ã®ããŸã第1å[1]ããã²èªãã§ãã ããããšãé²éªšãªå®£äŒã§åçš¿ãããã®ã§ãããã¿ãªããèªãã§ãããŸãããïŒ ãç¶ã»ãªãŒãã³ãµã€ãšã³ã¹ã®ããŸãã®åèšäºã¯ææ°å·ããããªãŒã¢ã¯ã»ã¹ïŒCC BYå ¬éãªã®ã§ãªãŒãã³ã¢ã¯ã»ã¹ãšãåŒã¹ãŸãïŒã§ãã®ã§ããæ°è»œã«èªãã§ãã ãããïŒ
ãâŠâŠèªãã§ãããŸãããïŒ èªãã§ãããã¿ãªããã«ã¯ããã£ãŠããã ãããšããããªãŒãã³ã¢ã¯ã»ã¹éèªã®ç¹éå·ã®åé¡ãšã¯ãã²ã¹ãã»ãšãã£ã¿ãŒã«ããæ»èªã®ç®¡çäœå¶ãçããªããã¡ãªç¹ã«ããããããæšä»ã¯ã³ãããè«æå·¥å ŽïŒpaper millïŒãã«å©çšãããããšããããŸãããè«æå·¥å Žããšã¯è¿å¹Žæ¥æé·ããŠãããç ç©¶äžæ£ããžãã¹ïŒå°äžããžãã¹ïŒã§ãçµç¹çã«è«æã倧éã«ãçç£ããããã®èè ãšããŠååãå ¥ããæš©å©ãç ç©¶è ã«å£²ãã€ããããšã§å©çãåŸãæå£ã§ããåœç¶ãç ç©¶è ãäžæ£ã«ãéãæ¯æã£ãŠãŸã§æã«å ¥ãããã®ã¯ãæ»èªè«æããšããæ¥çžŸãªã®ã§ãè«æã®çç£éçšã«ãããŠã¯æ»èªãééããéèªã«æ²èŒãããå¿ èŠããããŸããã倧åã®å·¥å Žçç£è«æã¯æé ããææã«åºã¥ããŠããããæå³ã®ããå 容ãã»ãšãã©ãªãã£ãããããã®ãªã®ã§ãæ»èªãééããã®ã¯å°é£ã§ããããã§éèªã®ç·šéå§å¡ãè²·åããŠåã蟌ãããšããæå£ããšãããŠããã®ã§ãã[2]ããã®æšçãšããŠç¹éå·ã®ã²ã¹ãã»ãšãã£ã¿ãŒãçããããããããã¯ããããè«æå·¥å Žé¢ä¿è ãç¹éå·ã®ã²ã¹ãã»ãšãã£ã¿ãŒã«éã蟌ãŸãããããŠããŸãã
ãç¹éå·ã®åé¡ã«éãããè¿å¹Žã®åŠè¡æ å ±æµéé¢ä¿è ãæ©ãŸããŠãããè«æå·¥å Žãã§ãããä»å¹ŽïŒ2024幎ïŒã«ãªã£ãŠãããšã¯ãŸãç°ãªããããã䌌ããããªã¿ã€ãã®ãå·¥å Žãã®ååšãææãããŠããŸããããããæ»èªå·¥å ŽïŒreview millïŒãã§ãã
ïŒïŒãæ»èªå·¥å ŽïŒreview millïŒãçºèŠã®å段éïŒæ»èªã®åœçª
ããæ»èªå·¥å Žãã®ååšãææããã®ã¯ã¹ãã€ã³ã»ã»ããªã¢å€§åŠã®Oviedo-GarcÃaæ°ã§ãããããã«ãã®æºæµã¯æ»èªã«ãããåœçªã®æšªè¡ãææãããããŒã©ã³ãã»ã¯ã«ã·ã£ã¯çåœç§åŠå€§åŠã®Piniewskiæ°ãã®èª¿æ»ã§ãã[3]ãPiniewskiæ°ã¯ãèªèº«ãå ±èã«å ¥ã£ãŠãScience of The Total EnvironmentïŒElsevier瀟ãåè¡ïŒãšããéèªã«æçš¿ããŠãã2æ¬ã®è«æã«ã€ããŠãå¯ããããæ»èªã¬ããŒãã®äžã«äžèº«ã䌎ããªãæç« ãææ§ãªæç« ãå°éçšèªã®ééã£ãäœ¿ãæ¹çããããç¬åµæ§ã®çããããã®ãããããšã«æ°ãä»ããŸãããããã§è©Šãã«æ»èªã¬ããŒãããªã³ã©ã€ã³åœçªæ€ç¥ããŒã«ã«ãããŠã¿ããšããã1æ¬ç®ã®è«æã§ã¯æ»èªã¬ããŒã4æ¬äžã3æ¬ã§é¡äŒŒåºŠã44ïœ89%ã2æ¬ç®ã®è«æã§ã¯æ»èªã¬ããŒã3æ¬äžã2æ¬ãé¡äŒŒåºŠ44ïœ100%ãšãä»ã®æç« ãšã®é¡äŒŒãææãããŸãããè«æã®å Žåãäžè¬ã«ã¯åœçªæ€ç¥ããŒã«ã§ã®é¡äŒŒåºŠã®ææã10ïœ15%ãè¶ ãããšç·šéå§å¡ã®ç®èŠãã§ãã¯ãå ¥ãã¬ãã«ãšãããŠãã[4]ãè«æãšæ»èªã¬ããŒããšããéããããã«ããŠããããªãé«ãé¡äŒŒåºŠã«ãªã£ãŠããŸãã
ãããã§Piniewskiæ°ãã¯ãã詳现ãªèª¿æ»ãè¡ã£ãŠã¿ãããšã«ããŸããããŸããåœçªã®çããé«ããšãããæ»èªã¬ããŒãã®ãã¡ã®1ã€ãä»ã®æç« ãšã®é¡äŒŒåºŠã59%ãšææããããã®ã«ã€ããŠãäžèº«ã1ïœ3æãã€ã«çްããåãåããŠã¿ãäžã§ãåæãGoogleã§æ€çŽ¢ããŠã¿ãŠãé¡äŒŒã®æç« ãèŠã€ãããã調ã¹ãŸããããã®çµæããã®æ»èªã¬ããŒãäžã®è¡šçŸã«ã€ããŠã22ã®ç°ãªãæ»èªã¬ããŒãçãšã®éã§ã»ãšãã©äžèŽããäŸãçºèŠãããŸããã22ã®æ»èªã¬ããŒããå±ããåéã¯ã°ãã°ãã§ãããã©ããªåéã«ãéãããããªææ§ãªè¡šçŸãäŸãã°ãã©ãã«ç ç©¶ã®ã£ããããããç ç©¶ã®ãŽãŒã«ã¯ãªããªã®ãããã£ãšèª¬æãå¿ èŠã§ãããç ç©¶ã®ã£ãããšç ç©¶ç®çã詳ãã説æãããŠããªããããèªè ã¯ç ç©¶ã®æçŸ©ãèŠéããŠããŸãããšãã£ãæç« ã䜿ããŸããããŠããŸãããæ§ã ãªåéã®ææ§ãªè¡šçŸãã€ãã¯ãããã³ã©ãŒãžã¥ãšããŠãçæã®æ»èªã¬ããŒããäœæãããŠããã®ã§ãã
ãããã«Piniewskiæ°ãã¯ãæ»èªã¬ããŒãäžã«å«ãŸããŠããäžã€ã®æç« ãéžæãããã®äœ¿ããŸããç¶æ³ããã¯ãGoogleã§èª¿ã¹ãããšã«ããŸãããéžã°ããã®ã¯ãæ¬ç ç©¶ã®å€§ããªæ¬ ç¹ã¯ãå°å ¥éšã§è°è«ã䞻匵ãæç¢ºã«è¿°ã¹ãããŠããªãããšã§ããããããã£ãŠãã®ç ç©¶ã®ïŒç ç©¶åéãžã®ïŒè²¢ç®åºŠã¯åŒ±ããçè«çãªè°è«ã匷åããèšè«ã»è°è«ãæ·±ããããšãææ¡ãããããšããæã§ãé·ãããšã«å ããŠãå ã®è±æã§ã¯è€æ°ã®æç« ã®èª€ããªã©ãå«ãŸããŠããŸããïŒäŸãã°The major defect of this study is the debate or ArgumentâŠãšãæã®éäžã§åºæåè©ã§ããªãã®ã«åèªã®å é ã倧æåã«ãªã£ãŠããããšããããªã©ïŒãããã ãé·ãæã§ããã€èª€ããŸã§åããã®ãããã°ãå¶ç¶ã®äžèŽã§ã¯ãªãã ãããšããããã§ãã調æ»ã®çµæãã€ã³ã¿ãŒãããã§å ¬éãããŠããæ»èªã¬ããŒã50ä»¶ã§ããã®æç« ãã»ãŒé¡äŒŒããããªãšãŒã·ã§ã³ãçºèŠãããŸããã
ã50ä»¶ã®åœçªçææ»èªã¬ããŒãã®ãã¡37ä»¶ã¯æ»èªè åãå ¬éããŠããªãã£ãäžæ¹ãæ»èªè åãå ¬éããŠãã13ä»¶ã®ãã¡ãæ»èªè ãåäžäººç©ã§ããã®ã¯2ä»¶ã®ã¿ïŒ1åã®ã¿ïŒã§ã11ä»¶ã¯å¥ã ã®æ»èªè ã«ãããã®ã§ããããã£ãŠPiniewskiæ°ãã¯ãããæ»èªã¬ããŒãã®äœ¿ããŸããã§ã¯ãªããæ»èªã¬ããŒãã®åœçªãä»è ã«ããççšã§ãããšå€æããŸãããããããPiniewskiæ°ãã®è«æã«å¯ããããããå°æ°ã®æ»èªã¬ããŒãã«åºã¥ããŠããããšããŸãããªãŒãã³æ»èªãæ¡çšãããå ¬éãããŠããªãïŒä»åçºèŠã§ããŠããªãïŒæ»èªã¬ããŒãã®æ¹ãå€ãã ããããšãèãããšãä»åçºèŠãããã®ã¯æ°·å±±ã®äžè§ã§ãããæ»èªã¬ããŒãã®åœçªã¯ããèå»¶ããŠããå¯èœæ§ãããããšãããã«å¯Ÿããæ©æ¥ãªå¯Ÿçãå¿ èŠã§ããããšãPiniewskiæ°ãã¯æå±ããŠããŸãã
ãæ»èªè ãšããŠã¯ãïŒè«æãªããšãããïŒæ»èªã¬ããŒãã«ã€ããŠãããŸã§åŒ·ããªãªãžããªãã£ã䞻匵ãããã®ã§ããªãã®ã§åœçªãããŠãããŸããã³ãšæ¥ãªãæ°ãããŸããïŒèªåã®æèãäœãã ããããããŸãããïŒãææ§ãªè¡šçŸã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã§æ§æãããæ»èªã¬ããŒããªããŠæ»èªãšããŠã®æå³ããªããŠããªãã®ã§ãæ»èªã®è³ªä¿èšŒã®ããã§ã¯å€§åé¡ã§ãã
ãã¡ãªã¿ã«ãããæ¥çžŸã«ãªãè«æãªããšãããããªãããããã¬ããŒãã®åœçªãããŠãŸã§æ»èªãåŒãåããç ç©¶è ãããã®ããšããç¹ã«ã€ããŠãPiniewskiæ°ãã¯ãæ»èªè ãåŒãåããããšã§åŸãããAPCããŠãã£ãŒçã®ç¹å žãç®åœãŠã§ããå¯èœæ§ããäžéšã®åœã§ã¯ïŒäŸãã°Piniewskiæ°ãã®æå±ã§ããããŒã©ã³ãïŒæ»èªãåŒãåããåæ°ãæ¥çžŸè©äŸ¡æã«æåºãããã®ã§ããããããæ¥çžŸããå¢ããããã§ããå¯èœæ§ãèå¯ããŠããŸãããããã¯ããããããã²ã¿ã«åºççã«ãããŠãå®ã¯æ»èªããããªã£ãŠããªãããšãé ãç®ãããŸãã®ããã«ç·šéå§å¡ãæ»èªã¬ããŒããæé ããŠããå¯èœæ§ããæ»èªè ã«ãªãããšã§ç ç©¶ã¢ã€ãã£ã¢ã®ççšããç«¶äºçžæãžã®åŠšå®³å·¥äœããããªãããšããè ã®ããå¯èœæ§ã«ãè§ŠããŠããŸãããããããå¯èœæ§ã®åãåºãŸããããããã¯åçŽã«ãéè±èªåã®ç ç©¶è çããèªåã®èšèã§æ»èªã¬ããŒããæžãèªä¿¡ããªãã®ã§ãæ¢åã®æ»èªã¬ããŒãã®ã³ããã§æžããŠããããšããå¯èœæ§ãææãããŠããŸãã
ïŒïŒãæ»èªå·¥å Žãã®çºèŠ
ãPiniewskiæ°ãã®èª¿æ»ã§ã¯åäžäººç©ã«ããæ»èªã¬ããŒãã®äœ¿ããŸããã¯1äŸãããªãã£ããããäžé£ã®çºèŠãæ»èªã®ãåœçªããšããŠæ±ã£ãŠããŸããããããOviedo-GarcÃaæ°ã¯ãåäžäººç©ïŒæã«ã¯è€æ°äººã®ã°ã«ãŒãïŒããåãæ»èªã³ã¡ã³ããç°ãªãå¥ã ã®è«æã«å¯ŸããŠäœ¿ããŸãããŠããããããããèªå·±åœçªãã«ãããäºäŸã倿°ããããšããããåãªãèªå·±åœçªã§ã¯ãªããç¹å®ã®æå³ããã£ãŠãããªã£ãŠããããã§ããããšãçºèŠããŸãã[5]ã
ãOviedo-GarcÃaæ°ã®ããããã®åæ©ã¯æ»èªã®åœçªã§ã¯ãªããæ»èªã«ãããåŒçšã®åŒ·èŠïŒç·šéå§å¡ãèªèº«ã®éèªã®å¥ã®è«æã®åŒçšã匷èŠããããæ»èªè ãèªèº«ã®è«æã®åŒçšã匷èŠããããšã§ãéèªãå人ã®è¢«åŒçšæ°ã«åºã¥ãè©äŸ¡ãæäœããããšããæå£ïŒã®èª¿æ»ã«ãããŸãããã²ãããªããšããïŒè«æäžã§ã¯æããããŠããŸããããèªèº«ã®è«æã«å¯Ÿããæ»èªã§ããããïŒïŒåŒçšã®åŒ·èŠã«ééããOviedo-GarcÃaæ°ã¯ãåãæ»èªè ãä»ã®æ»èªã§ãåŒçšã®åŒ·èŠããããªã£ãŠããã®ã§ã¯ãªãããšèãã調ã¹ãŠã¿ãŸããããã®èª¿æ»ãé²ãããã¡ã«ãåã«åŒçšã®åŒ·èŠããããªã£ãŠããã ãã§ã¯ãªããåãæç« ã®äœ¿ããŸããã倿°ããããšã«æ°ãä»ããæç« ã®äžéšãšæ»èªè åã䜿ã£ãæ€çŽ¢ãçµã¿åãããŠã11çš®é¡ã»ã®ã¹263ä»¶ã®æç« ã䜿ããŸãããŠããæ»èªã¬ããŒããèŠã€ãããŸããïŒ2024幎5æ9æ¥æç¹ïŒããããã®æ»èªã¬ããŒãã®æ å ±ã¯ãã¹ãŠè«æã®ä»é²ãšããŠå ¬éãããŠããŸãã
ã263ä»¶ã®æ»èªã¬ããŒãäžã«ã¯æ»èªè åãå ¬éããŠããªããã®ãå«ãŸããŸãããæ°åãå ¬éããŠããæ»èªè ãåèš26åããŸããããã®ãã¡æãçæã®æ»èªã¬ããŒããå€ãïŒäžéšã«å¯Ÿè±¡è«æåºæã®è¡šçŸããããã®ã®ãææ§ã§ã©ããªè«æã«ã䜿ããããªè¡šçŸã«ã€ããŠã»ãšãã©äžèŽããŠããïŒã°ã«ãŒãã«ã¯åèš85ä»¶ã®æ»èªã¬ããŒãã»10人ã®ç°ãªãæ»èªè ãå«ãŸããŠããŸãããæ»èªè ãç°ãªããªãããã¯åœçªãªã®ã§ã¯ïŒããšæããããããŸããããåäžäººç©ã衚çŸã䜿ããŸãããŠããã±ãŒã¹ããã¡ããå€ãäžã«ã10åäžã«ã¯å ±èè«æãçºè¡šããŠãããªã©ãåãç ç©¶ã°ã«ãŒãã«å±ããç ç©¶è ãå€ããã°ã«ãŒããšããŠæ»èªã¬ããŒãã®äœ¿ããŸããããããªã£ãŠãããšèããæ¹ã劥åœããã§ããOviedo-GarcÃaæ°ã¯ãã®85ä»¶ã®æ»èªã¬ããŒããšãã®æ»èªè ãReview Mill 1ãšåä»ããŠããŸããããããã®æ»èªã¬ããŒãã§ã¯åºç€ã§âIn the abstract, the author should add more scientific findings.âïŒãæé²äžã«ç§åŠççºèŠãããæžãã¹ãããåèš³ã¯äœè€ã«ããã以äžåæ§ïŒãåŸåã§âComparison of the present results with other similar findings in the literature should be discussed in more detail. This is necessary in order to place this work together with other work in the field and to give more credibility to the present results.âïŒãä»åã®çµæãšãå è¡ç ç©¶ã«ããä»ã®åæ§ã®ç¥èŠãšã®æ¯èŒã«ã€ããŠããã詳现ã«è«ããã¹ãã§ãããããã¯ããã®ç ç©¶ããã®åéã«ãããä»ã®ç ç©¶ãšãšãã«äœçœ®ã¥ããä»åã®çµæã«ä¿¡ææ§ãæãããããã«å¿ èŠãªããšã§ããããïŒãæåŸã®æ¹ã§â The conclusion part is very week. Improve by adding the results of your studies.âïŒãçµè«éšåã¯éåžžã«åŒ±ããç ç©¶ã®ææãå ããŠæ¹åããŸãããããïŒãšãã»ãŒå¿ ãåãæèšã§ææããŸãããŸããããã€ãã®æç« ãè«ææ¬æããããã¯ã¢ããããŠâThe author should provide reason about this statement,âïŒãèè ã¯ãã®èšè¿°ã®çç±ã説æãã¹ãã§ãããïŒãšææããã®ããæ±ºãŸãã§ããè€æ°äººã§ãäžèº«ãšé¢ä¿ãªããã³ãã¬ãŒãã䜿ããŸãããŠãããšèŠãã®ãèªç¶ã§ãããã
ãããããããæšæºåããããã«ãã³ã³ãã€ãŒåŒçç£ãã®ããã«æ»èªã¬ããŒããéç£ãããŠããæ§åãåããŠãOviedo-GarcÃaæ°ã¯ãããã®æ»èªã¬ããŒãã®äœ¿ããŸããã»èªå·±åœçªããæ»èªå·¥å ŽïŒreview millïŒããšåä»ããŸããïŒå³å¯ã«ã¯åœåè ã¯æ°æ¬äººã§ã¯ãªããSNSã®ãã©ãã¯ãŒã ããã§ãïŒã
ããªããä»åçºèŠããããæ»èªå·¥å Žãäºæ¡ã¯98.1%ãšã»ãšãã©ãMDPIã®éèªã§ãããªãããŠãããã®ã§ããããå ¬éãããŠããæ»èªã¬ããŒãã®äžã«MDPIã®éèªã«æ²èŒããããã®ãå€ãããšãäžå ãšèããããã®ã§ããæ»èªå·¥å ŽããMDPIåºæã®åé¡ã§ãããšäœçœ®ã¥ããããããã§ã¯ãªãã§ãããã
ïŒïŒãªãã®ããã®ãå·¥å ŽããïŒ
ãè«æå·¥å Žãçµç¹çã«ãããªãããŠãããééç®çã®äžæ£ããžãã¹ã§ããã®ã«å¯Ÿããæ»èªå·¥å Žã®å Žåã¯å®æ ã¯ãŸã ããããã£ãŠããŸãããä»åç¹å®ãããäžã«ã¯ã°ã«ãŒãã«ãããã®ã°ããã§ã¯ãªããæ»èªè 1åã§æ°åä»¶ã®æ»èªã¬ããŒããããªããŠããå Žåããã£ãããã§ãã
ãç ç©¶è ããæ»èªå·¥å Žãã«æãæããçç±ã«ã€ããŠãOviedo-GarcÃaæ°ã¯å®æ ã¯æªè§£æã§ãããã®ã®ãåºæ¬çã«ã¯Piniewskiæ°ããææããæ»èªã®åœçªïŒä»è ããã®åœçªïŒã®åæ©ã¯æ»èªå·¥å Žã«ãããŠã¯ãŸãã ãããšããŠããŸããã€ãŸãæ¥çžŸãšããŠã®æ»èªã®æ°Žå¢ããæ»èªããããªãããšã§åŸãããç¹å žãèªåã®èšèã§æ»èªããããªãããšãžã®èªä¿¡ã®ãªããçã§ããããã«Oviedo-GarcÃaæ°ã¯ããã²ã¿ã«åºçã«ååããŠããå ŽåïŒããã¯Piniewskiæ°ããææïŒã®ã»ãã«ãè«æå·¥å Žã®åŽã«ååããŠãé©åœãªã»å¯Ÿå¿ããããæ»èªã¬ããŒããéç£ããŠããå¯èœæ§ãææããŠããŸãã
ãããããæ»èªå·¥å Žãã«ã¯ãããã¯ã£ããããåæ©ãååšãããšOviedo-GarcÃaæ°ã¯è¿°ã¹ãŸããããããã®åæ°ã®èª¿æ»ã®å¯Ÿè±¡ã§ãã£ããåŒçšã®åŒ·èŠã§ãããæ»èªå·¥å Žãã«å±ããæ»èªã¬ããŒãã®ã»ãšãã©ã¯ãæ»èªè èªèº«ãå ±èè ãå·çããè«æã远å ã§åŒçšããããšããæ¡é²ã®èŠä»¶ãšããŠå«ãã§ããŸããã»ãšãã©ãã³ãã¬ãŒãã®ã¿ã§æ§æãããæ»èªã¬ããŒããäœæãããã®äžã«èªåãã¡ã®è«æãåŒçšããããïŒãããã»ãŒãã³ãã¬ã§ïŒä»ãå ããã ãã§è¢«åŒçšæ°ã1å皌ããããã§ãèè ã«ãšã£ãŠã¯ãŒããå売ã§ãâŠâŠãã£ãšãããã®ã³ã¡ã³ãããªãŒãã³æ»èªã§å ¬éãããŠããå Žåã«ã¯ãåŒçšã®åŒ·èŠããŸãããããªããã§ããâŠâŠã
ïŒïŒãæ»èªå·¥å Žãã«å¯ŸåŠããã«ã¯
ããæ»èªå·¥å Žãã«å¯ŸåŠããæ¹æ³ã®å€ãã¯ãä»è ã«ããæ»èªã®åœçªãžã®å¯ŸåŠãšå ±éããŠããŸããäžã€ã¯ãPiniewskiæ°ããã£ãããã«ãæ»èªã¬ããŒãã«å¯ŸããŠåœçªæ€ç¥ããŒã«ãé©çšããããšã§ããæçš¿è«æã«å¯Ÿããåœçªæ€ç¥ããŒã«ã®é©çšã¯ãã§ã«å€ãã®éèªã§å®æœãããŠãããæ»èªã¬ããŒãã«ãããŠãåœçªãååšããããšãããã£ã以äžã¯ãæ»èªã¬ããŒãã«ãé©çšç¯å²ãæ¡å€§ããããšã¯åœç¶ãèããããŸããå®çªã®ææã®å Žåçã®é¡äŒŒã®è¡šçŸãŸã§æ€åºããŠããŸãçã®åé¡ã¯ãããŸãããããã¯åŠ¥åœæ§ãæ åœç·šéå§å¡ããã§ãã¯ããã°ãã話ã§ãããã ããè«æãšæ»èªã¬ããŒãã®éããšããŠãèè ãç©æ¥µçã«æçš¿ããããŠããŠããè«æã«å¯Ÿããéèªã®åŽããå¿ ãããä¹ãæ°ã§ã¯ãªãç ç©¶è ã«é Œãã§æžããŠããã£ãŠããæ»èªã¬ããŒãã«ã€ããŠãåœçªæ€ç¥ããŒã«ãé©çšããããšã¯æ»èªè ã®å¿èšŒã害ããåŒãåãæãæžãããŠããŸãæžå¿µããããŸã[3]ããŸããéå ¬éã®æ»èªã¬ããŒããšã®éè€ã¯ãåœçªæ€ç¥ããŒã«ã§ã¯æ€ç¥ã§ããŸãããå ¬éããªããŸã§ãåºç瀟éã§æ»èªã¬ããŒããå ±æããããšã§å¯ŸåŠããããšçã¯èããããŸãããããããæ çµã¿ããæ§ç¯ãããšãªããšåœçªæ€ç¥ããŒã«ã®é©çšã»ã©ç°¡åã«ã¯é²ãŸãªãã§ãããã
ãæ»èªã¬ããŒãã®å ¬éãããªãã¡ãããããªãŒãã³æ»èªïŒã®ãäžéšïŒã®æ¡çšãäžã€ã®ææ¢åã«ã¯ãªãåŸãŸãïŒãªãŒãã³æ»èªã®è©³çްã¯å¥çš¿åç §[6]ïŒãããããäžé£ã®åœçªããæ»èªå·¥å Žãã®çºèŠã¯å ¬éãããŠããæ»èªã¬ããŒãããªããã°å®çŸããªãã£ããã®ã§ãããããããŠçºèŠã»åçºãããããã«ãªãããšã§ãæ»èªåœçªãæ»èªå·¥å Žãææ¢ãã广ãæã¡åŸãâŠâŠãããããŸãããæ»èªã®åœçªã«ã€ããŠã¯ãå ¬éãããŠããæ»èªã¬ããŒããåœçªã®ã¿ãŒã²ããã«ãªããšããè² ã®åœ±é¿ã®å¯èœæ§ãææãããŠããŸãã[3]ããæ»èªå·¥å Žãã«ã€ããŠã¯ã©ããèªåãã¡ã®æ»èªã¬ããŒãã䜿ããŸãããŠããã®ã§ãå ¬éã®æç¡ã¯é¢ä¿ãããŸããããããæ»èªã¬ããŒããéå ¬éã®æ¹ãã䜿ããŸãããã°ããå±éºæ§ããããŸãããããã§ãªãŒãã³æ»èªã®æ¡çšã«ãã£ãŠãæ»èªå·¥å Žããææ¢ã§ããå¯èœæ§ãåºãŠæ¥ãâŠâŠããã§ãããçŸã«æ»èªã¬ããŒããå ¬éããæ»èªè åãå ¬è¡šããŠããç¶æ ã§å ã ãšå®è¡ããŠãããæ»èªå·¥å Žããããããšãèãããšãæ»èªã¬ããŒãã®å ¬éã ãã§ååãšã¯èšããªããããããŸãããããããããæ»èªå·¥å Žãææ¢ã ããç®çã«ãªãŒãã³æ»èªãå°å ¥ãããšããã®ããåºç瀟éã®æ»èªã¬ããŒãå ±æä»¥äžã«å®¹æã«é²ã話ã§ã¯ãªãã§ãããã
ãPiniewskiæ°ããOviedo-GarcÃaæ°ã®ããããããã¯ããã¹ãã§ãããšææããŠããã®ã¯ãåœçªè ããæ»èªå·¥å Žãé¢äžè ã®æ å ±ãæ²èŒãããã©ãã¯ãªã¹ãã®äœæã»å ±æã§ããçŸåšããã®ã¿ã€ãã®æ»èªäžæ£ã«é¢ãã察åŠã«ã€ããŠã¯åºçèŠç¯å§å¡äŒïŒCOPEïŒã«åãæ±ºãããããŸããããæ»èªè ã«ããè«æã¢ã€ãã£ã¢ã®ççšãšåæ§ã«ããæ»èªå·¥å Žãçãžã®å¯ŸåŠã«ã€ããŠãã¬ã€ãã©ã€ã³ãçå®ãã¹ãã§ãããšOviedo-GarcÃaæ°ã¯è¿°ã¹ãŠããŸãã
ãããã«ããŠãããè«æå·¥å Žãã«ãšã©ãŸãããæ»èªå·¥å ŽããåºãŠãããšã¯ã次ããæ¬¡ãšè²ã ãªæå£ãåºãŠãããã®ã§ãâŠâŠãã以äžãæããããã¬ãå·¥å Žãã«ã¯åºãŠããŠã»ãããªããã®ã§ããâŠâŠã
[1] äœè€ç¿. ãªãŒãã³ã¢ã¯ã»ã¹éèªã«ãããç¹éå·ïŒSpecial IssueïŒã®åé¡ïŒIssueïŒ. æ å ±ã®ç§åŠãšæè¡. 2024, vol.74, no.7, p.267-270. https://doi.org/10.18919/jkg.74.7_267, (åç §2024-08-22).
[2] Joelving, F. Paper trail. Science. 2024, vol.383, no.6680, p.252-255. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.ado0309, (åç §2024-08-22).
[3] Piniewski, M. et al. Emerging plagiarism in peer-review evaluation reports: a tip of the iceberg?. Scientometrics. 2024, vol.129, p.2489-2498. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-024-04960-1, (åç §2024-08-22).
[4] Lykkesfeldt, J. Strategies for using plagiarism software in the screening of incoming journal manuscripts: Recommendations based on a recent literature survey. Basic & Clinical Pharmacology & Toxicology. 2016, vol.119, no.2, p.161-164. https://doi.org/10.1111/bcpt.12568, (åç §2024-08-22).
[5] Oviedo-GarcÃa, M.Ã. The review mills, not just (self-)plagiarism in review reports, but a step further. Scientometrics. 2024. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11192-024-05125-w, (åç §2024-08-22).
[6] äœè€ç¿. ãªãŒãã³æ»èªã®ååïŒèæ¯ãç¯å²ããã®æ¯é. ã«ã¬ã³ãã¢ãŠã§ã¢ãã¹. 2021, no348, CA2001, p.20-25. https://doi.org/10.11501/11688293, (åç §2024-08-22).

Â
æïŒäœè€ ç¿ïŒ åå¿ç€Ÿå€§åŠ ïŒ
1985幎çãŸãã2012å¹ŽåºŠçæ³¢å€§åŠå€§åŠé¢åå£«åŸæèª²çšå³æžé€šæ å ±ã¡ãã£ã¢ç ç©¶ç§ä¿®äºãå士ïŒå³æžé€šæ å ±åŠïŒã2013幎床ããåå¿ç€Ÿå€§åŠå©æã2018幎床ããååææã2024幎床ããåææã
峿žé€šæ å ±åŠè ãšããŠãã£ã¡ãã£ã¡ã®ããŒãã«æãåºããŠããŸãããåå£«è«æã¯æ©é¢ãªããžããªã®å©çšç ç©¶ã§åã£ãŠãããåŠè¡æ å ±æµéïŒãªãŒãã³ã¢ã¯ã»ã¹ã¯ä»ãæãäž»ããããŒãã ãšæã£ãŠããŸãã
åŠéšçæä»£ãã峿žé€šã»å³æžé€šæ å ±åŠçãããã¯ãæ±ãããã°ãããã€ããã¯é»å峿žé€šã®å€¢ãã¿ããããéå§ãããã°ã®æŽæ°ã¯çµ¶è³æ»ã£ãŠãããã®ã®ãçŸåšã¯éèªãã©ã€ãã©ãªãŒã»ãªãœãŒã¹ã»ã¬ã€ãïŒLRGïŒãèªäžã§ååã®é£èŒãæ¯å·å·çäžãæ¬é£èŒã¿ã€ãã«ãããã«ã¡ãªãã ãã®ããªãããã«è² ããã«åã©ããè²ãŠãŠããã²ãŸããã¯ç«æŽŸã«å²ããŸããããæ©ãã«å²ããããšããã£ãŠ8æã«ã¯æ¯ããŠããŸããŸãããããã£ãŠåŠæ ¡ããæã¡åž°ã£ãã¢ãµã¬ãªãç«æŽŸã«è²ã¡ãè²ã¡éããŠçé¢å ã®éµäŸ¿åããå®å šã«ã¢ãµã¬ãªã®ã€ãã«åã蟌ãŸããŠããŸãã
